10 thoughts on “For Jesus Christ our Savior was Born upon This Day – And other Myths, Legends and Traditions that created the Modern Christmas

  1. Jacqueline Fisher says:

    I found this very interesting.

     
  2. Jacqueline Fisher says:

    I found this very interesting.

     
  3. Delmar says:

    I agree that your blog is really interesting and I ALWAYS enjoy reading it. But as an avid history reader and researcher, I find it a wee bit frustrating that you don’t have any source notes for any (as far as I have found) of your really great articles. Couldn’t you provide a separate sources page at least, if you won’t/don’t want to put them at the end of each article? Is every single article written by you entirely, or are most/all of them excerpts from other works? Even if you wrote them, paraphrased from other sources, those sources would be interesting to know. Especially about the Titanic material. Also essential if one wants to take you seriously as a nonfiction writer, since otherwise there’s no guarantee that the material is factual and accurate (assuming you weren’t around when, for instance, the Titanic sunk or Christmas was invented). If you don’t cite, then pretty much everything you write must unfortunately be considered hearsay rather than confirmed fact. This is not a criticism, just a reality. And mentioned only because I find it disappointing and frustrating that nothing is cited here. In the world of publishing, all professional writers of nonfiction are required to cite their sources!

     
    • scheong says:

      Hi Delmar,

      I write a LOT and listing all the sources for all my articles can be tricky. If it helps you and other readers, when I get more time on my hands (which I don’t currently have), I’ll be glad to compile a ‘Sources’ page on my blog, listing as many of the pages and websites that I used to find any and all such information.

       
  4. Delmar says:

    I agree that your blog is really interesting and I ALWAYS enjoy reading it. But as an avid history reader and researcher, I find it a wee bit frustrating that you don’t have any source notes for any (as far as I have found) of your really great articles. Couldn’t you provide a separate sources page at least, if you won’t/don’t want to put them at the end of each article? Is every single article written by you entirely, or are most/all of them excerpts from other works? Even if you wrote them, paraphrased from other sources, those sources would be interesting to know. Especially about the Titanic material. Also essential if one wants to take you seriously as a nonfiction writer, since otherwise there’s no guarantee that the material is factual and accurate (assuming you weren’t around when, for instance, the Titanic sunk or Christmas was invented). If you don’t cite, then pretty much everything you write must unfortunately be considered hearsay rather than confirmed fact. This is not a criticism, just a reality. And mentioned only because I find it disappointing and frustrating that nothing is cited here. In the world of publishing, all professional writers of nonfiction are required to cite their sources!

     
    • scheong says:

      Hi Delmar,

      I write a LOT and listing all the sources for all my articles can be tricky. If it helps you and other readers, when I get more time on my hands (which I don’t currently have), I’ll be glad to compile a ‘Sources’ page on my blog, listing as many of the pages and websites that I used to find any and all such information.

       

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *